| The World According to Chris | Jeanna de Waal, Ben Thompson, Christy Altomare, Derek Klena, Carrie: The Musical Ensemble | 4:40 | |
| My Own Best Friend | Gwen Verdon | 2:41 | |
| Urinetown | Jeff McCarthy, Urinetown Ensemble | 1:40 | |
| Top of the World | Andrew Keenan-Bolger, Sarah Charles Lewis, Tuck Everlasting Original Broadway Cast Ensemble | 2:36 | |
| Purpose | John Tartaglia, Avenue Q Ensemble | 2:28 | |
| Sonya & Natasha | Brittain Ashford, Denée Benton | 4:12 | |
| Manage Your Flamingo | Noah Galvin, Alice By Heart Original Cast Recording Company, Duncan Sheik, Steven Sater | 2:24 | |
| Why We Like Spelling | 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Original Cast | 2:51 | |
| Finale | 'Something Rotten' Company, Wayne Kirkpatrick, Karey Kirkpatrick | 2:31 | |
| Mr. Girl Hater | Megan McGinnis, Paul Alexander Nolan | 1:41 | |
| Extraordinary | Matthew James Thomas | 2:38 | |
| Hello | Bob Martin, 'The Drowsy Chaperone' Original Broadway Cast | 1:16 | |
| Zazz | Angie Schworer, Caitlin Kinnunen | 2:47 | |
| I Love the Way | Kate Reinders, John Cariani, Wayne Kirkpatrick, Karey Kirkpatrick | 2:49 | |
| Blood in the Water | 'Legally Blonde' Ensemble, Michael Rupert | 4:49 | |
| When Velma Takes the Stand | Bebe Neuwirth | 2:13 | |
| Toledo Surprise | Garth Kravits, Jason Kravits, Lenny Wolpe, Jennifer Smith, 'The Drowsy Chaperone' Original Broadway Cast | 4:30 | |
| An Operatic Tragedy | Mindi Dickstein, Jason Howland, 'Little Women' Original Broadway Cast | 1:57 | |
| Cop Song | Jeff McCarthy, Daniel Marcus, Rachel Coloff, Rick Crom, Victor W. Hawks, Megan Lawrence, Lawrence Street, Kay Walbye | 2:43 | |
| Legally Blonde - Remix | Kate Shindle, Laura Bell Bundy, 'Legally Blonde' Ensemble, Natalie Joy Johnson | 4:59 | |