| Finale | Hunter Parrish, Uzo Aduba, Nick Blaemire, Celisse Henderson, Morgan James, Telly Leung | 6:28 | |
| Please, Don't Take Him | Michael Mulheren, Carmen Cusack, Stephen Lee Anderson, Dee Hoty, William Youmans, Bright Star Original Broadway Ensemble | 2:27 | |
| Lost in the Brass | Gaby Alter, Tommy Newman, Mark Allen, Lindsay Mendez | 3:49 | |
| I'm Trying | Hunter Foster, Lisa Brescia | 4:47 | |
| Opening: The New World | 'Songs for a New World' 2018 Encores! Off-Center Company | 5:18 | |
| Out of the Blue | Julia Murney, Brian D'Arcy James | 4:02 | |
| Moving Too Fast | Norbert Leo Butz | 4:46 | |
| Secondary Characters | Heidi Blickenstaff, Susan Blackwell | 2:25 | |
| Nothing Short of Wonderful | Lindsay Mendez | 2:40 | |
| Chapter 18 - Master Harold and the Boys | Athol Fugard, Leon Addison Brown, Keith David, Bobby Steggert | 3:16 | |
| Extraordinary | Matthew James Thomas | 2:38 | |
| Carrie - Reprise | Marin Mazzie, Molly Ranson | 1:25 | |
| She Cries | Brooks Ashmanskas | 4:49 | |
| Climbing Uphill | Sherie Rene Scott | 3:36 | |
| On My Way | Jeanine Tesori, Brian Crawley, Sutton Foster, Violet Company | 4:18 | |
| Favorite Places | Hunter Foster | 3:48 | |
| We Beseech Thee | Nick Blaemire, Godspell (The New Broadway Cast Recording) | 3:23 | |