| What’s Next | Norbert Leo Butz, Bobby Steggert, Big Fish Original Broadway Cast | 3:31 | |
| I Know a Guy | Corey Cott, James Nathan Hopkins, Brandon J. Ellis, Alex Bender, Geoff Packard, Joe Carroll, Bandstand Ensemble | 3:11 | |
| A Man's Gotta Do - Reprise | Michael Mulheren, Bright Star Original Broadway Ensemble | 2:50 | |
| As We Stumble Along - Reprise | Bob Martin, 'The Drowsy Chaperone' Original Broadway Cast | 2:35 | |
| Letters | Original Broadway Company of Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 | 6:27 | |
| You Can't Trust a Man | Michael Wartella, Fred Applegate | 3:26 | |
| The Acceptance Song | Christopher Sieber, Beth Leavel, Brooks Ashmanskas, The Prom Ensemble | 3:14 | |
| Nobody Needs to Know | Norbert Leo Butz | 7:00 | |
| Everything and More | Original StarKid Cast of Twisted, Rachael Soglin | 3:49 | |
| All for the Best | Hunter Parrish, Wallace Smith, Godspell (The New Broadway Cast Recording) | 3:16 | |
| Raised by Wolves | Ethan Slater, Norbert Leo Butz, Lilli Cooper, Nick Blaemire | 3:07 | |
| Finale | Patina Miller, Matthew James Thomas, Andrew Cekala, Ashton Woerz, The Players | 7:30 | |
| I've Decided to Marry You | Lauren Worsham, Lisa O'Hare, Bryce Pinkham | 4:03 | |
| Ilona | Gavin Creel | 3:04 | |
| The Book Report | You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown Ensemble (1999) | 5:10 | |
| Motherhood | Kate Baldwin, Bette Midler, Beanie Feldstein | 1:40 | |
| You're Changing | Norbert Leo Butz, Michael Deaner, Michael Mahler, Alan Schmuckler | 2:51 | |
| Serious | Laura Bell Bundy, Richard H. Blake | 3:13 | |
| You've Got Nothing, Pt. 2 | Paul Alexander Nolan, Wade McCollum, Stan Brown, Joe De Paul, Water for Elephants Company, PigPen Theatre Co. | 3:13 | |
| Barry Is Going to Prom | Brooks Ashmanskas | 2:33 | |
|