| Can I | J Mascis | 5:25 | ||
| Hearts of Iron | Handsome Furs | 3:35 | ||
| Song for Leigh | The Walkmen | 3:38 | ||
| The Empty Threats of a Little Lord | Sunset Rubdown, Spencer Krug | 5:07 | ||
| She Haunts My Dreams | Spain | 3:11 | ||
| Stupid Things | Yo La Tengo | 5:05 | ||
| Get Up and Go | Jason Lytle | 2:15 | ||
| Benediction | Thurston Moore | 5:16 | ||
| Underneath The Weeping Willow | Grandaddy | 2:40 | ||
| The World in 1984 | Shearwater | 3:01 | ||
| My Own Face Inside the Trees | The Clientele | 3:08 | ||
| Tightrope | Yeasayer | 3:18 | ||
| Do You Really Wanna Know | Papercuts | 3:14 | ||
| Manitoba | Tapes 'n Tapes | 4:12 | ||
| Jenny & The Ess-Dog | Stephen Malkmus | 2:45 | ||
| Worthy of Your Esteem | Hayden | 3:26 | ||
| Donde Esta La Playa | The Walkmen | 3:55 | ||
| My Will Is Good | Port O'Brien | 3:51 | ||
| One with the Freaks | The Notwist | 3:38 | ||
| One Last Dance | Badly Drawn Boy | 4:48 | ||
| Dear Sarah Shu | John Vanderslice | 4:29 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Willow Wand Willow Wand | Jason Lytle | 3:47 | ||
| Reappearing Rat | Sunset Rubdown | 3:20 | ||
| New Drink for the Old Drunk | Crooked Fingers | 3:52 | ||
| The Agony Of Laffitte | Spoon | 3:28 | ||
| There Goes My Outfit | The Dears | 3:46 | ||
| Red | Okkervil River | 3:40 | ||
| I've Smoked Too Much | Lawrence Arabia | 5:34 | ||
| You Must Be out of Your Mind | The Magnetic Fields | 3:12 | ||
| While I Shovel the Snow | The Walkmen | 4:00 | ||
| Saint Mary | Marie-Thérèse, Jason Lytle | 4:09 | ||
| I Guess I'll Take Care | Midlake | 3:19 | ||
| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| My Heart is an Apple | Arcade Fire | 4:27 | ||
| Queen Black Acid | Menomena | 4:47 | ||
| This Is Just a Modern Rock Song | Belle and Sebastian | 7:12 | ||
| Old Shit / New Shit | Eels | 3:15 | ||
| Up Above the Sea | John Vanderslice | 3:41 | ||
| Neon Bible | Arcade Fire | 2:16 | ||
| Deep Down | Calexico | 4:31 | ||
| It's All In My Mind | Teenage Fanclub | 3:41 | ||
| Many Rivers to Cross | The Walkmen | 4:42 | ||
| City of Daughters | Destroyer | 2:35 | ||
| Michigan | Ambulance LTD | 4:30 | ||
| No Key, No Plan | Okkervil River | 3:00 | ||
| Hangtown | Jason Lytle | 3:51 | ||
| Old Flame | Arcade Fire | 3:59 | ||
| Drink To Me, Babe, Then | A.C. Newman | 3:32 | ||
| Who Are You, Defenders of the Universe? | The Dears | 3:42 | ||
