| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| Fin | Supergrass | 3:11 | ||
| King Fish Pies | Midlake | 4:20 | ||
| Southern Point | Grizzly Bear | 5:02 | ||
| Looking for Astronauts | The National | 3:23 | ||
| Mornington Crescent | Belle and Sebastian | 5:40 | ||
| Waitin' for a Superman - Mokran Mix; 2017 Remaster | The Flaming Lips, Peter Mokran | 4:19 | ||
| Life#2 | Lambchop | 4:43 | ||
| In the Ground | Midlake | 4:11 | ||
| Spiders And Flies | Mercury Rev | 4:11 | ||
| Was All Talk | Kurt Vile | 7:41 | ||
| Return to Form | Daniel Rossen | 5:23 | ||
| Muzzle of Bees | Wilco | 4:52 | ||
| Meet Me Here at Dawn | Cass McCombs | 3:39 | ||
| Gone | The Beta Band | 3:41 | ||
| While I Shovel the Snow | The Walkmen | 4:00 | ||
| The First Time | Richard Swift | 3:56 | ||
| So You'll Aim Toward The Sky | Grandaddy | 4:43 | ||
| Reprise | Grizzly Bear | 3:19 | ||
| Freeze the Saints | Stephen Malkmus | 3:54 | ||
| Paper Gown | Midlake | 4:30 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Cornelia and Jane | Yo La Tengo | 4:49 | ||
| Pregnant Pause | Cass McCombs | 3:29 | ||
| An Actor's Revenge | Destroyer | 2:57 | ||
| So Far Around the Bend | The National | 3:42 | ||
| Fortune | Midlake | 2:03 | ||
| Life's A Dream | Built To Spill | 4:53 | ||
| Hold Time | M. Ward | 3:05 | ||
| Underneath The Weeping Willow | Grandaddy | 2:40 | ||
| Stone on the Water | Badly Drawn Boy | 3:58 | ||
| Donald pleasance | Flotation Toy Warning | 9:27 | ||
| Out of the Woodwork | Courtney Barnett | 5:50 | ||
| Climbing To The Moon | Eels | 3:38 | ||
| My Heart is an Apple | Arcade Fire | 4:27 | ||
| Battery Kinzie | Fleet Foxes | 2:49 | ||
| Suicide Demo for Kara Walker | Destroyer | 8:25 | ||
| Killjoy | The Czars | 5:26 | ||
| He Tried To Escape | Midlake | 4:30 | ||
| Sometimes I Don't Get You | Yo La Tengo | 3:16 | ||
| A Voice At The End Of The Line | M. Ward | 2:14 | ||
| In Ear Park | Department Of Eagles | 4:04 | ||
| Antiphon | Midlake | 3:16 | ||
| Post-War | M. Ward | 4:55 | ||
| Art of Almost | Wilco | 7:16 | ||
| Whipping Boy | Shearwater | 4:42 | ||
| Gentle Spirit | Jonathan Wilson | 6:27 | ||
| J Smoov | Stephen Malkmus & The Jicks | 5:06 | ||
| Powder Blue | Elbow | 4:31 | ||
| Forgiveness | Girls | 7:49 | ||
