| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| Each Time I Bring It up It Seems to Bring You Down | Lambchop | 4:25 | ||
| Half Moon | M. Ward | 2:51 | ||
| By Some Miracle | Philip Selway | 2:37 | ||
| Get Up and Go | Jason Lytle | 2:15 | ||
| Masterfade | Andrew Bird | 4:10 | ||
| Meet Me Here at Dawn | Cass McCombs | 3:39 | ||
| Next Train | Miracle Fortress | 4:16 | ||
| Paper Gown | Midlake | 4:30 | ||
| I'll Be Lightning | Liam Finn | 4:14 | ||
| Jesus Fever | Kurt Vile | 3:46 | ||
| My Descent Into Madness | Eels | 3:54 | ||
| Val | The Czars | 5:06 | ||
| Rising Red Lung | Wilco | 3:09 | ||
| New Friend | The Concretes | 4:11 | ||
| Lakes Of Canada | Karen Peris, Don Peris, The Innocence Mission | 4:33 | ||
| Roscoe | Midlake | 4:46 | ||
| A Century of Fakers | Belle and Sebastian | 4:29 | ||
| Sun It Rises | Fleet Foxes | 3:11 | ||
| Weightlifting | Trashcan Sinatras | 4:39 | ||
| Willow Wand Willow Wand | Jason Lytle | 3:47 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Benediction | Thurston Moore | 5:16 | ||
| Spiders And Flies | Mercury Rev | 4:11 | ||
| Flushed Chest | Joan As Police Woman | 3:55 | ||
| The First Time | Richard Swift | 3:56 | ||
| Trojan Curfew | Stephen Malkmus | 4:06 | ||
| Little Eyes | Yo La Tengo | 4:22 | ||
| Matterhorn | Jason Lytle | 5:15 | ||
| Say It Again | Badly Drawn Boy | 4:41 | ||
| Once We Walked In The Sunlight | Papercuts | 5:09 | ||
| You Masculine You | Lambchop | 5:59 | ||
| I'm Sleeping in a Submarine | Arcade Fire | 2:47 | ||
| Children of the Grounds | Midlake | 3:55 | ||
| Miner At The Dial-A-View | Grandaddy | 5:21 | ||
| Robin Egg Blue | Cass McCombs | 3:41 | ||
| I Believe in You | Lambchop | 3:27 | ||
| How I Long | Gorky's Zygotic Mynci | 4:08 | ||
| Morning Comes | The Feelies | 4:12 | ||
| The Old and the Young | Midlake | 5:36 | ||
| Jacking the Ball | The Sea and Cake | 3:52 | ||
| Saint Nothing | Daniel Rossen | 4:50 | ||
| Stupid Things | Yo La Tengo | 5:05 | ||
| The Upper Peninsula | Sufjan Stevens | 3:23 | ||
| River Of Dirt | Marissa Nadler | 4:26 | ||
| Around the Bay | Department Of Eagles | 5:08 | ||
| Fire Snakes | Laura Veirs | 4:57 | ||
| The Postman | The American Analog Set | 2:59 | ||
| Heart Attack | Kurt Vile | 3:09 | ||
| Vitamin K | Gruff Rhys | 3:04 | ||
