| Say | Cat Power | 3:24 | ||
| We Gathered in Spring | Midlake | 3:32 | ||
| An Actor's Revenge | Destroyer | 2:57 | ||
| Give a Little Love (feat. Sufjan Stevens) | Mina Tindle, Sufjan Stevens | 3:37 | ||
| Springfield, or Bobby Got a Shadfly Caught in his Hair | Sufjan Stevens | 4:17 | ||
| Also Frightened | Animal Collective | 5:14 | ||
| Always Be My Baby | Rosie Thomas, The Shins, Sufjan Stevens, Josh Ottum | 4:14 | ||
| Milk Thistle | Conor Oberst | 5:21 | ||
| Underneath The Weeping Willow | Grandaddy | 2:40 | ||
| Bunker or Basement | Fionn Regan | 6:26 | ||
| Dreamed I Saw Soldiers | Neil Halstead | 6:20 | ||
| Moon | Bryce Dessner, James McAlister, Nico Muhly, Sufjan Stevens | 3:42 | ||
| Dream Scream | Death Cab for Cutie | 6:58 | ||
| Details of the War | Clap Your Hands Say Yeah | 3:30 | ||
| Floating on the Lehigh | Department Of Eagles | 6:08 | ||
| Afford | Akron/Family | 3:57 | ||
| The War Criminal Rises and Speaks | Okkervil River | 5:11 | ||
| The Perpetual Self, or "What Would Saul Alinsky Do?" | Sufjan Stevens | 2:24 | ||
| When the God of Love Returns There'll Be Hell to Pay | Father John Misty | 4:04 | ||
| Come Back From San Francisco | The Magnetic Fields | 2:48 | ||
| Angels' Share | Vetiver | 4:21 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Maine Island Lovers | Okkervil River | 4:51 | ||
| Hollow Bedroom | Waxahatchee | 1:51 | ||
| Sylvia | The Antlers | 5:27 | ||
| Flint (For the Unemployed and Underpaid) | Sufjan Stevens | 3:43 | ||
| Ode to Divorce | Regina Spektor | 3:42 | ||
| Creature Fear | Bon Iver | 3:06 | ||
| Brother Bryan | Waxahatchee | 2:36 | ||
| Tailor | Julie Doiron | 2:34 | ||
| Women Know | Blake Mills | 4:33 | ||
| Now, Now | St. Vincent | 4:25 | ||
| What Is the Light? - 2017 Remaster | The Flaming Lips | 4:05 | ||
| Covered in Dust | Andy Shauf | 2:49 | ||
| The Giant Of Illinois | Andrew Bird | 4:44 | ||
| Hannah Happiest | Lomelda | 3:46 | ||
| When You're Old and Lonely | The Magnetic Fields | 1:57 | ||
| Lovers Of The World | Julie Doiron | 1:56 | ||
| Winters Love | Animal Collective | 4:55 | ||
| Atrophy | The Antlers | 7:40 | ||
| Headlights Look Like Diamonds | Arcade Fire | 4:25 | ||
| Joe by the Book | Buck Meek | 1:52 | ||
| Metal Heart | Cat Power | 4:02 | ||
| Laughing with a Mouth of Blood | St. Vincent | 3:01 | ||
| Sister | Sufjan Stevens | 6:00 | ||
| Stairs to the Attic | The Antlers | 4:36 | ||
| Blue Mountain Road | Florist | 3:39 | ||
| City Middle | The National | 4:27 | ||
| Simple X | Andrew Bird | 3:36 | ||
| Broken Dreams Club | Girls | 5:12 | ||
