| Humiliation | The National | 5:00 | ||
| If She Wants Me | Belle and Sebastian | 5:05 | ||
| Detlef Schrempf | Band of Horses | 4:28 | ||
| I'm Not Talking | A.C. Newman | 4:38 | ||
| Acid Tongue | Jenny Lewis | 3:50 | ||
| Afterlife | Arcade Fire | 5:53 | ||
| 90-Mile Water Wall | The National | 3:44 | ||
| Best Night | The War On Drugs | 5:30 | ||
| I Will Never See the Sun | Great Lake Swimmers | 3:35 | ||
| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| Challengers | The New Pornographers | 3:31 | ||
| While I Shovel the Snow | The Walkmen | 4:00 | ||
| I'll Keep The Things You Throw Away | Badly Drawn Boy | 3:50 | ||
| Cold Girl Fever - 2021 Remaster | The National | 4:06 | ||
| Gone for Good - 2023 Remaster | The Shins | 3:12 | ||
| Daphne | Lia Ices, Justin Vernon | 5:21 | ||
| Swim Until You Can't See Land | Frightened Rabbit | 4:19 | ||
| I Can See the Pines are Dancing | A.A. Bondy | 3:42 | ||
| Brothers | The War On Drugs | 4:29 | ||
| We Can't Be Beat | The Walkmen | 4:42 | ||
| Abel | The National | 3:37 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Sun It Rises | Fleet Foxes | 3:11 | ||
| El Caporal | My Morning Jacket | 3:33 | ||
| It Ain't Easy | Woods | 2:23 | ||
| Paint the Moon | The Czars | 4:11 | ||
| Still | Great Lake Swimmers | 2:51 | ||
| Turn On Me | The Shins | 3:41 | ||
| There From Here | Phosphorescent | 5:20 | ||
| Plus Ones | Okkervil River | 3:43 | ||
| Green Gloves | The National | 3:39 | ||
| Mamah Borthwick (A Sketch) | Conor Oberst | 4:14 | ||
| Older | Band of Horses | 3:28 | ||
| North Star Lover | Fionn Regan | 5:20 | ||
| Crooked Legs | The Acorn | 5:07 | ||
| Lucky You | The National | 4:22 | ||
| The Great Exhale | Great Lake Swimmers | 4:38 | ||
| Maureen | Vetiver | 3:32 | ||
| Holy Shit | Father John Misty | 4:01 | ||
| Terror in the Canyons (The Wounded Master) | Phosphorescent | 4:05 | ||
| Sow Mare Bitch Vixen | Fionn Regan | 3:45 | ||
| Arms Like Boulders | The War On Drugs | 5:20 | ||
| The Past and Pending - 2021 Remaster | The Shins | 5:25 | ||
| We Are Nowhere and It's Now | Bright Eyes | 4:12 | ||
| Start a War | The National | 3:16 | ||
| The Soul Serene | Villagers | 4:10 | ||
| The First Days Of Spring | Noah And The Whale | 6:39 | ||
| Blue Skies | Noah And The Whale | 4:07 | ||
| Ahead Of The Curve | Monsters Of Folk | 3:40 | ||
| Oh My God, Whatever, Etc. | Ryan Adams | 2:31 | ||
