| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| How Will I Find You? | Jeff Tweedy | 6:05 | ||
| One of Us Cannot Be Wrong | Father John Misty | 7:32 | ||
| Ragged Wood | Fleet Foxes | 5:07 | ||
| Bird | Bedouine | 5:17 | ||
| Razzle Dazzle Rose | Camera Obscura | 5:28 | ||
| Tightrope | Yeasayer | 3:18 | ||
| On a Neck, On a Spit | Grizzly Bear | 5:46 | ||
| Name Written in Water | Cass McCombs | 2:52 | ||
| Classical Records | Department Of Eagles | 2:51 | ||
| You Love Me | DeVotchKa | 4:02 | ||
| An Empty Corner | Wilco | 3:46 | ||
| Naked, If I Want To | Cat Power | 2:47 | ||
| How Past Begins | Angelo De Augustine | 4:37 | ||
| Funtimes in Babylon | Father John Misty | 3:39 | ||
| Designer | Aldous Harding | 4:16 | ||
| All the Land Glimmered Beneath | Julie Byrne | 3:04 | ||
| I Know It's Pathetic but That Was the Greatest Night of My Life | Sun Kil Moon | 1:47 | ||
| Meadowlarks | Fleet Foxes | 3:11 | ||
| I Went to the Store One Day | Father John Misty | 4:25 | ||
| When You Know Why You're Happy | Richard Reed Parry, Little Scream | 4:58 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| I Was Young When I Left Home | Antony, Bryce Dessner | 4:55 | ||
| Call Yourself Renee | Okkervil River | 7:07 | ||
| On My Way Home | Angelo De Augustine | 4:54 | ||
| St Mary's County | Hamilton Leithauser | 3:11 | ||
| Give My Body Back | The Low Anthem | 2:01 | ||
| You Belong To Heaven | Luke Temple | 5:09 | ||
| 100 Acres Of Sycamore | Fionn Regan | 5:35 | ||
| You Can't Hide A Light With The Dark | Bill Ryder-Jones | 3:38 | ||
| Little Garçon | Born Ruffians | 4:09 | ||
| Summer Song | James Yorkston | 4:26 | ||
| On Your Side | The Innocence Mission | 3:34 | ||
| 1959 | Hamilton Leithauser, Rostam, Angel Deradoorian | 4:52 | ||
| Mimizan | Beirut | 2:42 | ||
| Swing Lo Magellan | Dirty Projectors | 2:37 | ||
| Song To Bobby | Cat Power | 4:18 | ||
| Meet Me Here at Dawn | Cass McCombs | 3:39 | ||
| One More Time | Bedouine | 4:19 | ||
| The Underwood Typewriter | Fionn Regan | 3:01 | ||
| Not a Heel | Phosphorescent | 3:50 | ||
| White Sheet Lightning | Tiny Ruins | 3:22 | ||
| Fellows | Daughter of Swords | 3:51 | ||
| Black Chair | Twain | 4:14 | ||
| My Best Friends (Don't Even Pass This) | Kurt Vile | 4:36 | ||
| Me and My Friend | Julie Doiron | 2:45 | ||
| Can We Really Party Today? | Jonathan Wilson | 6:40 | ||
| Blue Ridge Mountains | Fleet Foxes | 4:25 | ||
| Lived in Bars | Cat Power | 3:44 | ||
| Sweetest Kill | Broken Social Scene | 5:09 | ||
