| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| The Nest | José González | 2:23 | ||
| Detlef Schrempf | Band of Horses | 4:28 | ||
| Old Friend | Alex Ebert | 5:02 | ||
| He Always Felt Like Dancing | Mark Kozelek & Jimmy LaValle | 7:56 | ||
| The Brussels Rambler | James Yorkston | 4:14 | ||
| Mbira In The Morass | Volcano Choir | 3:51 | ||
| Josephine | Magnolia Electric Co., Jason Molina | 3:22 | ||
| For Prayer | Wye Oak | 3:50 | ||
| Diamond Heart | Marissa Nadler | 3:47 | ||
| Below It | Peter Broderick | 4:01 | ||
| Echoes Of The Lonely | Scott Matthews | 4:05 | ||
| Twenty Cycles To The Ground | Jason Molina, Will Johnson | 3:07 | ||
| Where I'm Calling From | Adam Torres | 5:45 | ||
| We Were Wasted | The Leisure Society | 2:55 | ||
| The Big Surprise | The Felice Brothers | 4:22 | ||
| Pretty, Pt. 1 | Phosphorescent | 2:22 | ||
| Heart My Heart | Jason Molina | 1:43 | ||
| Vodka Sorrow | Fionn Regan | 6:04 | ||
| Morning Dove | Julie Byrne | 2:59 | ||
| Put You to Sleep | Dolorean | 3:49 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Give My Body Back | The Low Anthem | 2:01 | ||
| I'll Be Around | Yo La Tengo | 4:47 | ||
| All We Grow | S. Carey | 4:38 | ||
| Benediction | Thurston Moore | 5:16 | ||
| Backstage With The Modern Dancers | Great Lake Swimmers | 4:28 | ||
| Defibrillation | The Barr Brothers, Lucius | 5:33 | ||
| Woodberry Cemetery | Fionn Regan | 1:43 | ||
| It's Beyond Me | Vetiver | 6:36 | ||
| Shut In | Strand of Oaks | 3:21 | ||
| Way Out Weather | Steve Gunn | 6:17 | ||
| Tortoise Regrets Hare | James Yorkston | 3:57 | ||
| Sleepless | The Decemberists | 7:53 | ||
| My Grandma Was Pearl Hall | The Middle East | 5:28 | ||
| Cornelia and Jane | Yo La Tengo | 4:49 | ||
| Me Again | J Mascis | 4:24 | ||
| Drink Deep | Laura Veirs | 4:36 | ||
| Catcher Song | Great Lake Swimmers | 4:11 | ||
| The Giant Of Illinois | Andrew Bird | 4:44 | ||
| Fold | José González | 2:54 | ||
| Passerby | Luluc | 4:30 | ||
| This is the Last Time | The National | 4:43 | ||
| Twenty Seven Strangers | Villagers | 3:24 | ||
| Fire-scene | S. Carey | 4:35 | ||
| No Names | Mutual Benefit | 2:27 | ||
| A Nervous Tic Motion of the Head to the Left | Andrew Bird | 4:59 | ||
| Underneath The Weeping Willow | Grandaddy | 2:40 | ||
| Faithful Night, Listening | Great Lake Swimmers | 4:08 | ||
| Hard To Love A Man | Magnolia Electric Co., Jason Molina | 4:18 | ||
