| One Plus One Is One | Badly Drawn Boy | 4:18 | ||
| Don't Ask | Grizzly Bear | 3:28 | ||
| Let the Cool Goddess Rust Away | Clap Your Hands Say Yeah | 3:24 | ||
| In Line | Sharon Van Etten | 4:44 | ||
| Tall Saint - Demo | The National | 3:44 | ||
| This Is Just a Modern Rock Song | Belle and Sebastian | 7:12 | ||
| Your Protector | Fleet Foxes | 4:09 | ||
| For the Dishwasher | Grandaddy | 3:53 | ||
| I Will Call You Lover Again | Loney Dear | 2:47 | ||
| Secret Meeting | The National | 3:44 | ||
| Pittsfield | Sufjan Stevens | 6:51 | ||
| Sleepless | The Decemberists | 7:53 | ||
| Heartswarm | Swan Lake | 4:34 | ||
| My Favorite Year | Destroyer | 6:07 | ||
| Dead Of Winter | Eels | 2:59 | ||
| Feeling No Pain | Josh Rouse | 4:19 | ||
| Kick | Conor Oberst | 3:39 | ||
| Fiery Crash | Andrew Bird | 4:12 | ||
| Falling Through Your Clothes | The New Pornographers | 2:53 | ||
| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| Break Me | Sharon Van Etten | 4:01 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| All I Want | LCD Soundsystem | 6:41 | ||
| Tightrope | Yeasayer | 3:18 | ||
| City with No Children | Arcade Fire | 3:11 | ||
| Slipped | The National | 4:25 | ||
| Thinking of a Dream I Had | The Walkmen | 4:27 | ||
| Sun It Rises | Fleet Foxes | 3:11 | ||
| Josephine | Magnolia Electric Co., Jason Molina | 3:22 | ||
| Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) | Arcade Fire | 5:12 | ||
| A Century of Fakers | Belle and Sebastian | 4:29 | ||
| Laredo | Band of Horses | 3:12 | ||
| Heretics | Andrew Bird | 3:33 | ||
| Baby We'll Be Fine | The National | 3:21 | ||
| Mighty Sword | The Frames | 9:40 | ||
| Castaways | Shearwater | 3:16 | ||
| Unguided | The New Pornographers | 6:33 | ||
| A Girl In Port | Okkervil River | 6:36 | ||
| Underneath The Weeping Willow | Grandaddy | 2:40 | ||
| She Sends Kisses | The Wrens | 5:57 | ||
| Spring Cleaning | Bright Eyes, Neva Dinova | 4:13 | ||
| Weather | Meursault | 4:21 | ||
| The History of Plastic | The War On Drugs | 8:04 | ||
| Cold Days from the Birdhouse | The Twilight Sad | 6:13 | ||
| Demons | The National | 3:31 | ||
| I Lost You | The Walkmen | 3:31 | ||
| Sovay | Andrew Bird | 4:41 | ||
| On and on and On | Wilco | 4:01 | ||
| Blue Plastic Bags | Malcolm Middleton | 3:24 | ||
| Get It Wrong, Get It Right | Feist | 3:37 | ||
