| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| These Old Shoes | Deer Tick | 2:20 | ||
| Julia | Ray LaMontagne | 3:21 | ||
| Leap | The Cave Singers | 3:49 | ||
| Muzzle of Bees | Wilco | 4:52 | ||
| Hold Your Head High | Heartless Bastards | 5:05 | ||
| Mayla | Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros | 5:42 | ||
| Impressions of the Past | Megafaun | 5:32 | ||
| New Theme | The Shouting Matches | 4:17 | ||
| Water From The Well | Beachwood Sparks | 3:41 | ||
| Cheers | Blake Mills | 3:32 | ||
| In The Twilight | Alex Ebert | 3:14 | ||
| Shut In | Strand of Oaks | 3:21 | ||
| Angel Blood | Cass McCombs | 3:43 | ||
| Dragon | The Amazing | 3:13 | ||
| Love Me Tenderly | The Felice Brothers | 3:40 | ||
| Rolling Sea | Vetiver | 5:18 | ||
| The Chorus In The Underground | Great Lake Swimmers | 3:21 | ||
| A Million Years | Alex Ebert | 4:51 | ||
| Griffiths Bucks Blues | Ryley Walker | 2:47 | ||
| Lazy Suicide | Megafaun | 6:20 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| O Little Light | Hiss Golden Messenger | 4:17 | ||
| Gone Tomorrow | Lambchop | 6:59 | ||
| Bramble | The Cave Singers | 2:55 | ||
| Naked | Sera Cahoone | 3:25 | ||
| Lapse | Bill Callahan | 6:29 | ||
| One Monkey | Gillian Welch | 5:38 | ||
| God's Love To Deliver | Jim James | 3:36 | ||
| Brothers | The War On Drugs | 4:29 | ||
| Baby's Arms | Kurt Vile | 3:56 | ||
| Street Keeper | Steve Gunn | 5:43 | ||
| Solid Ground | Megafaun | 4:50 | ||
| Hardwood Pews | Horse Feathers, Justin Ringle, Peter Broderick | 2:36 | ||
| Barfly | Ray LaMontagne | 3:55 | ||
| Cool Criminal | The Cave Singers | 4:19 | ||
| Benediction | Thurston Moore | 5:16 | ||
| Whole Love | Wilco | 3:49 | ||
| Down to Go | Phosphorescent | 5:16 | ||
| Can't You Tell | Vetiver | 4:25 | ||
| Wildwood | Steve Gunn | 5:37 | ||
| Brothers | The War On Drugs | 5:13 | ||
| Fit Against the Country | Horse Feathers | 3:31 | ||
| Stop Signs | The Moondoggies | 4:34 | ||
| You Are My Face | Wilco | 4:37 | ||
| Black Rain, Black Rain | A.A. Bondy | 3:14 | ||
| Loser | Ed Droste, Binki Shapiro, Friends | 5:15 | ||
| Dear God (Sincerely M.O.F.) | Monsters Of Folk | 5:06 | ||
| Fly High | Jay Farrar, Will Johnson, Anders Parker, Yim Yames | 3:45 | ||
| Old L.A. | Jay Farrar, Will Johnson, Anders Parker, Yim Yames | 3:03 | ||
