| Runner Ups | Kurt Vile | 4:00 | ||
| Sailors in Your Mouth - Bob's Buskers | Bob's Burgers, The National | 2:29 | ||
| It Covers the Hillsides | Midlake | 3:11 | ||
| Singer Songwriter | Okkervil River | 3:49 | ||
| Secret Meeting | The National | 3:44 | ||
| Leonard | Sharon Van Etten | 3:48 | ||
| Half Light II (No Celebration) | Arcade Fire | 4:27 | ||
| Ship Of Promises | Villagers | 4:36 | ||
| The Peacock | Beirut | 2:26 | ||
| I Love You, Honeybear | Father John Misty | 4:38 | ||
| Society Is My Friend | Kurt Vile | 5:39 | ||
| While I Shovel the Snow | The Walkmen | 4:00 | ||
| Paul Is Alive | EL VY | 3:30 | ||
| Holy Grail | Badly Drawn Boy | 8:12 | ||
| Leopard and Lamb | John Grant | 4:41 | ||
| She Haunts My Dreams | Spain | 3:11 | ||
| Title Track | Okkervil River | 5:22 | ||
| The Giant Of Illinois | Andrew Bird | 4:44 | ||
| One by One All Day | The Shins | 4:08 | ||
| Love At First Feel | Mark Kozelek | 2:12 | ||
| My Wandering Days Are Over | Belle and Sebastian | 5:25 | ||
| Unlock more with Songs Like X Pro | ||||
| Suburban War | Arcade Fire | 4:45 | ||
| Libby's First Sunrise | Destroyer | 5:59 | ||
| Heartbreaker | The Walkmen | 3:15 | ||
| Steel On Steel | J. Tillman | 4:39 | ||
| Shut In | Strand of Oaks | 3:21 | ||
| I Didn't See It Coming | Belle and Sebastian | 5:02 | ||
| See You on Rooftops | Neil Halstead | 6:34 | ||
| Matterhorn | Jason Lytle | 5:15 | ||
| The Mercy Wheel | A.A. Bondy | 3:48 | ||
| The Bear | My Morning Jacket | 4:39 | ||
| Wasp Nest - 2021 Remaster | The National | 3:22 | ||
| Hate Music | Owl John | 2:47 | ||
| Careless | EL VY | 3:21 | ||
| Josephine | Magnolia Electric Co., Jason Molina | 3:22 | ||
| I'll Keep The Things You Throw Away | Badly Drawn Boy | 3:50 | ||
| Alcoholiday | Benjamin Gibbard | 4:55 | ||
| Maureen's | Strand of Oaks | 3:39 | ||
| What's in It for Me | The Walkmen | 2:48 | ||
| Ada | The National | 4:03 | ||
| Old Flame | Arcade Fire | 3:59 | ||
| I Needed It Most | My Morning Jacket | 6:36 | ||
| Myriad Harbour | The New Pornographers | 4:00 | ||
| The Great Exhale | Great Lake Swimmers | 4:38 | ||
| Where I Found You | Future Islands | 5:44 | ||
| Always The Good | Neil Halstead | 4:28 | ||
| Collar Of Your Shirt | Matt Berninger | 5:14 | ||
| Be Mine | R.E.M. | 5:32 | ||
| Serpentine Prison | Matt Berninger | 4:32 | ||
