| Shiksa Goddess | Jeremy Jordan | 4:05 | |
| Till We Reach That Day | Marin Mazzie, Peter Friedman, Steven Sutcliffe, Vanessa Townsell-Crisp, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Judy Kaye, Ragtime Ensemble | 4:11 | |
| Bye Bye Birdie - Original Broadway Cast: The Telephone Hour | Charles Strouse, Bye Bye Birdie Ensemble, Elliot Lawrence | 3:02 | |
| Fancy Dress | 'The Drowsy Chaperone' Original Broadway Cast | 4:55 | |
| Razzle Dazzle | Jerry Orbach, Chicago Ensemble | 3:09 | |
| I Guess I'll Miss the Man | Rachel Bay Jones | 2:06 | |
| Opening / You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown | You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown Ensemble (1999) | 5:01 | |
| When You're Good to Mama | Marcia Lewis, David Warren-Gibson | 3:22 | |
| My Name! | Miles Anderson | 2:44 | |
| Follow Your Heart | Hunter Foster, Jennifer Laura Thompson | 4:47 | |
| Waiting for Life | Hailey Kilgore, Once On This Island Storytellers | 3:25 | |
| Another Life | Whitney Bashor | 5:17 | |
| Find My Way / Finale | Laura Bell Bundy, Orfeh, 'Legally Blonde' Ensemble | 5:03 | |
| As We Stumble Along - Reprise | Bob Martin, 'The Drowsy Chaperone' Original Broadway Cast | 2:35 | |
| Off with Their Heads | Karen Mason, Wonderland Ensemble | 3:00 | |
| When Velma Takes the Stand | Bebe Neuwirth | 2:13 | |
| I've Decided to Marry You | Lauren Worsham, Lisa O'Hare, Bryce Pinkham | 4:03 | |
|