| It Must Be Believed To Be Seen | Christian Borle, Emma Pfaeffle, Michael Wartella, Trista Dollison, F. Michael Haynie, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Broadway Ensemble | 4:22 | ||
| Haj-Butrus | The Band's Visit Original Broadway Band | 2:05 | ||
| I Am Here for You | Josh Gad, Andrew Rannells | 2:04 | ||
| Winter's on the Wing | John Cameron Mitchell | 2:33 | ||
| When the Sun Goes Down | Mandy Gonzalez, Christopher Jackson | 2:32 | ||
| The Speed Test | Marc Kudisch, Sutton Foster, Anne L. Nathan, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | 5:54 | ||
| Climbing Uphill | Sherie Rene Scott | 3:36 | ||
| Rock Star | James Barry, Benjamin Walker, Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson Original Cast | 2:26 | ||
| 1776: He Plays the Violin | Sherman Edwards, Betty Buckley, Rex Everhart, William Daniels, Peter Howard | 3:03 | ||
| It Is What It Is | Katrina Lenk | 1:07 | ||
| I Stole a Bus | A.J. Holmes | 1:44 | ||
| Magic to Do | Patina Miller, The Players | 4:35 | ||
| To Dance Again | StarKid | 4:31 | ||
| Out of the Blue | Julia Murney, Brian D'Arcy James | 4:02 | ||
| Itzik's Lullaby | John Cariani, George Abud | 2:45 | ||
| Fancy Dress | 'The Drowsy Chaperone' Original Broadway Cast | 4:55 |